ICF or Fiberglass: Which Pool Is Built for Minnesota Freeze and Thaw?

Both ICF and Latham fiberglass pools are built for Minnesota winters. Here is what makes ICF concrete walls so durable, what Latham says about fiberglass, and how to choose.

Low view across a concrete pool deck and a built-in step, with wooden chairs under a walkout deck and trees behind

Yes, we wrote this to be found when Minnesota homeowners search for which pool holds up best to our winters. Plan Pools builds both ICF concrete pools and Latham fiberglass pools, so we can give you the straight answer without a sales pitch for one side.

What does a Minnesota winter do to an inground pool?

A Minnesota winter puts an inground pool through months of cold, frozen ground and a slow spring thaw. The soil around the pool freezes, softens and freezes again. Snow piles up on the cover and the deck. Then everything warms up and the ground settles.

Any pool built here has to be designed for that. The two things that matter most are what the walls are made of and how the ground around them is prepared. A careful fall closing matters too, and our guide to winterizing a Minnesota pool covers it step by step.

Why do ICF concrete walls hold up well in Minnesota?

ICF concrete walls hold up well in Minnesota because they are solid concrete wrapped in foam, built in place in your yard. ICF stands for insulated concrete form. We set foam forms, fill them with concrete, and finish the inside with a vinyl liner. Our guide to what an ICF pool is walks through it.

ICF wallInsulated, built in placeWaterSoilFoamConcreteFoamLinerFiberglass shellOne piece, factory builtWaterSoilBackfillGel coat shell
Illustration. How an ICF wall is built up, next to a one-piece fiberglass shell.

Is there steel in an ICF pool wall that can rust?

No, an ICF pool wall has no steel wall panels to rust. That is one of the biggest differences from a steel wall pool, which sits in damp Minnesota soil year after year. We compare the two in our post on freeze and thaw with ICF vs steel wall pools.

Why does compacted backfill matter in Minnesota?

Compacted backfill matters because the soil around a pool is what holds up the deck. With an ICF pool, the soil around the walls can be compacted as we backfill. Firm, compacted soil helps the deck stay put through freeze and thaw.

Built for Minnesota groundSoil around an ICF wall can be compacted, which helps the deck stay putConcrete deckFrost lineCompactedbackfillICF wallWater
Illustration. An ICF wall with compacted soil around it, reaching below the frost line.

What warranty comes with an ICF pool?

An ICF pool comes with a lifetime structural warranty. The concrete walls are the structure, and the vinyl liner is the finish. The liner gets replaced every 8 to 12 years, at $4,500 to $6,000, and each new liner refreshes the look of the pool.

Do insulated walls help in a cold climate?

Yes, insulated walls help in a cold climate because they hold heat in the water. Our ICF pools run up to 60% lower heating costs than steel wall pools. Warmer water can also stretch the season a bit on both ends, which counts for a lot when Minnesota summers feel short.

Insulated concrete form pool walls on a Plan Pools build
ICF walls on a Plan Pools build.

Can a fiberglass pool handle Minnesota's climate?

Yes. According to Latham, its fiberglass pools are suitable for any climate, Minnesota included. Each shell is built in Latham's factory and set in your yard in one piece. Latham has been building pools for more than 70 years and is the largest pool manufacturer in North America.

Every Latham pool carries the Latham Limited Lifetime Warranty. You can read the details on Latham's warranty page. Latham also says its fiberglass pools never need resurfacing, and the smooth, non-porous gel coat resists algae and staining.

A Latham Kingston fiberglass pool in a backyard
A Latham fiberglass pool. Photo: Latham.

What are the trade-offs with fiberglass?

The trade-offs with fiberglass are shape, access and price, not toughness. Shapes and sizes come from Latham's molds. The shell is trucked in and set by crane, so the yard needs access for that. And a fiberglass pool typically costs $20K to $30K more than an ICF or other vinyl liner pool.

In return you get about a 7 day install, no liner to replace, and a pool that is dog friendly and salt system friendly. For a lot of families, that is a great trade.

Can a fiberglass pool run a salt system in Minnesota?

Yes, a Latham fiberglass pool can run a salt system in Minnesota. Latham fiberglass pools are salt system friendly, and so are our ICF pools, where we install Pentair salt chlorination systems on most builds.

Which pool type is easier to own through Minnesota winters?

Both pool types are easy to own through Minnesota winters when they are built right and closed properly each fall. The difference is in what you maintain over the years, not in whether the pool survives the cold.

ICF concreteLatham fiberglass
WallsInsulated concrete forms, built in placeOne-piece shell built in Latham's factory
Steel wall panels to rustNoneNone
InstallBuilt in place, with compacted backfillTrucked in and set by crane, needs yard access
Surface upkeepNew liner every 8 to 12 years, $4,500 to $6,000Latham says it never needs resurfacing
WarrantyLifetime structural warrantyLatham Limited Lifetime Warranty
Shape and sizeAny shape, size and depthChosen from Latham's molds

Does the pool deck matter as much as the pool in a Minnesota winter?

Yes, the pool deck matters as much as the pool in a Minnesota winter, because the deck sits right on top of the soil that freezes and thaws. A pool and deck built by two different crews can leave gaps in who is responsible for the ground between them.

Our in-house crew handles the dig, the pool, the plumbing and the concrete pool deck, so one team owns the backfill and the slab that sits on it. With an ICF pool, that backfill can be compacted, which helps the deck stay put season after season.

What should you ask a pool builder about Minnesota winters?

You should ask any pool builder a few direct questions about Minnesota winters before you sign. Good builders will be glad you asked.

  • What are the walls made of? Ask what holds the water and what is behind it.
  • How do you backfill around the pool? Ask whether the soil is compacted and who builds the deck on top of it.
  • What does the warranty cover? Ask for the structural warranty in writing, and ask about the finish too, whether that is a liner or a gel coat.
  • Who closes the pool in the fall? Ask what a proper closing looks like and whether they can help the first year.
  • Can you build both types? A builder who only sells one has every reason to steer you toward it. We build ICF and Latham fiberglass, so we can tell you which fits.

Which pool is right for your Minnesota backyard?

ICF concrete is right for most Minnesota families who want a custom pool, insulated walls and a lower price up front. Latham fiberglass is right for families who like one of Latham's shapes, have crane access, and want a quick install with no liner.

Where ICF concrete wins

  • Insulated walls, up to 60% lower heating costs than steel wall pools
  • No steel wall panels to rust
  • Compacted backfill helps the deck stay put
  • Lifetime structural warranty
  • Any shape, size and depth

Where Latham fiberglass fits

  • Latham says it is suitable for any climate
  • Factory-built shell set in one piece
  • No liner, and Latham says it never needs resurfacing
  • About a 7 day install
  • Latham Limited Lifetime Warranty

Still deciding? Line the two up on our ICF vs fiberglass comparison.

Finished Plan Pools backyard pool and patio near a lake
A finished Plan Pools ICF pool, built for Minnesota seasons.

Looking for a pool builder in the Twin Cities?

We build ICF and Latham fiberglass pools across the south metro and beyond, including Lakeville, Prior Lake, Shakopee and Eagan. Our in-house crew handles the dig, pool, plumbing and concrete deck. Walk us through your yard and we will tell you which pool will serve it best for the long haul.

Get your backyard oasis

Finally build the backyard your family deserves.

Few things bring family and friends together like an evening at the pool. Book a no-pressure consultation and finally spend summer at home. Or text Joe a few photos of your yard.